I had a lot of response, that I’ve dicided to make a top 5 of both ways. A top 5 of all the responses I got from you….
I’ve made a top 5 of the ones that you must have tasted ones in a lifetime.
- Yamazaki 1984 Vintage Malt
- 30 yr MacDuff
- Glenglassaugh 26, 37 and 45 year olds.
- Glenlivet Nadurra
- Port Charlotte 5 yo
And a top 5 of the ones that you wouldn’t recommend to others
- Jack Daniels
- Johnny Walker Red Label
- Black Velvet Canadian Whiskey
- Loch Lomond
- Frysk Hinder
Now.. I’d love to know … Do you agree with this top 5?
Enlightened us and let Whisky Girl know on twitter: Girl_Whisky or Facebook: The.Whisky.Girl
Comments
Powered by Facebook Comments
BenRiach 1975 – 2011 Asta Morris
Caperdonich 1972 – 2011 Perfect Dram
Springbank 21 – 2001 release
Thank you…. will make a note
Oh, and these:
- 1950′s or 1960 Macallan 10yo (get if at Dutch Connection at any festival they’re at).
- Brora 1974-2004
- Heavily sherried Karuizawa from at least the early ’80s or ’70s
- Some prohibition time bourbon
Karuizawa ‘Noh’ 1976, 32 yo, 63.0%ABV, cask #6719. The first Japanese malt that really massively impressed me and opened my eyes to the very high quality of whisky attained by Japanese distilleries…
Thank you… will take this one in my review ..
Bruichladdich’s Octomore.
Port Ellen.
A must have I presume
Have you ever try Benrinnes…. “The Bottlers 17y 60.2% cask strength” WOOOOW… I’m absolutely keen on this stunning good stuff…
Cheers
WfB
Not yet… It’s a must have I hear
For me at this moment: Caol Ila, the Moch bottle !!!
Thank you! And what whisky would you not recommend to others…
Ha ha Johnny Walker red label
Johnny it is.. thank you
Glenlivet Nadurra, preferrable batch 0407C! 59,7% cask strength, non-chill filtered. One of my favorite whiskies of all time
Thank you
It’s easy to say 5 whiskies you should try or 5 you should never recommend BUT I think it’s important you say why? I might really dislike Jack Daniels but I will tell you it’s because I really don’t like any whiskies that are sour mash. So tell us Femke, why would you recommend or not recommend these whiskies?
This isn’t my choice… This is the choice of the public! I had a lot of responses through mail, here, Twitter and Facebook. One of 10 told me why .. These whiskies made the top 5, cause of the most Thumbs up… or down!
I might make my own top 5 both ways …
Missing Kilchoman in the top-5 “lifetime”-list… Yummy stuff!